By Olivia Nabaggala
Makindye Division Mayor Hajji Yasin Omari has raised concern over what he described as conflicting judicial decisions in election petitions, warning that inconsistencies could undermine public confidence in the Judiciary.

Omari expressed the concern during the Court Open Day held at Makindye Chief Magistrate’s Court, which provided an opportunity for members of the public to interact with judicial officers and raise concerns about the administration of justice.
He cited the Makindye East parliamentary election petition, in which National Resistance Movement (NRM) flag bearer Judith Abaho challenged the academic qualifications of National Unity Platform (NUP) candidate Alhaji Kasirye Nganda Mulyanyama.
Omari noted that Justice Andrew Khaukha dismissed the petition, ruling that the matter ought to have been addressed by the Electoral Commission at the nomination stage.

However, he questioned why Justice Simon Peter Kinobe later relied on nomination-related grounds to nullify the election of Bugweri District Woman MP Stella Maris Nankwanga over academic qualification concerns, declaring her challenger, Aminah Mutesi Nalugoda, the rightful winner.
Omari argued that the differing approaches to what he considered comparable legal issues could create public confusion and erode confidence in the Judiciary.
He also questioned the transfer of the Makindye magistrate in the middle of hearing election petitions, noting that the division had more than 31 such cases.

Omari singled out Election Petition No. 22, which was presided over by Buganda Road Chief Magistrate Her Worship Rita Kidasa.
He said the petitioners presented a letter from the Chief Registrar questioning the status of a commissioner for oaths who had endorsed a candidate’s nomination papers.
According to Omari, the letter indicated that the individual was neither an advocate nor a duly appointed commissioner for oaths.
However, he said the magistrate declined to admit the letter as evidence on grounds that it had not been certified, despite originating from the office of the Chief Registrar.
The affected parties have since appealed, hoping that the higher court will reconsider the evidence.
Omari also used the occasion to call for the promotion of Makindye Chief Magistrate Sarah Basemera, whom he described as diligent and professional.

He argued that judicial officers who demonstrate commitment and competence should be rewarded through promotions, noting that Basemera had remained at the magistrate level for close to ten years.
Meanwhile, Makindye Division Minister for Gender, Community Services and Production Maureen Kyomugisha called on the Judiciary to intervene in disputes involving market vendors who have allegedly been arrested and imprisoned over rent arrears, despite a presidential directive prohibiting rent collection in public markets.
Kyomugisha revealed that some traders, including elderly vendors aged 75 and 80, were being held at Luzira Prison over the disputed payments.
She appealed to the Chief Magistrate to intervene and explore ways of securing their release, arguing that minor disagreements involving market vendors should be resolved through Local Council structures instead of lengthy and costly court proceedings.
Mayor Omari supported the proposal, saying LC1 and LCII courts should be empowered to handle minor disputes to ease congestion in the formal justice system.
In her response, Principal Judge Jane Frances Abodo, who was the chief guest, cautioned political leaders against dragging judicial officers into political disputes, particularly those arising from election petitions.
Abodo explained that transfers of judicial officers are sometimes necessary to safeguard their independence and protect them from political confrontations arising from their decisions.
She advised individuals dissatisfied with court rulings to follow established legal procedures, including filing appeals, rather than confronting or intimidating judicial officers.
On the disputes involving market vendors, Abodo encouraged greater dialogue between judicial officers and local leaders to identify cases that could appropriately be resolved through Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms.
She noted that dialogue and alternative dispute resolution could help settle minor disputes without unnecessarily burdening courts with cases that can be resolved outside the formal judicial process.
